College campuses are used to being a flashpoint for heated political speech. But as war rages in Gaza, outrage among some donors to America's elite institutions is boiling over.
This week, several high-profile donors have said they would yank their donations to the University of Pennsylvania, and at least one is calling for the school's president to resign over what they see as insufficient condemnation of antisemitic behavior on campus. At Harvard, a nonprofit founded by billionaire Les Wexner said it would cut ties with the university over its "tiptoeing" on terror attacks against Israel.
Among the donors who say they're cutting off funding to UPenn are former US Ambassador Jon Huntsman and private equity billionaire Marc Rowan. On Wednesday, venture capitalist David Magerman said he would halt donations to the school and urged all "self-respecting" Jews to do the same.
How we got here
UPenn hosted a Palestinian literary festival last month, featuring some writers who, according to the school's own leaders, had a history of making antisemitic remarks. UPenn issued a statement ahead of the festival condemning antisemitism broadly. But after Hamas' attack on Israel earlier this month, simmering resentments over the event turned to a boil.
The backlash against Harvard started over a letter from student groups that blamed Israel's "apartheid regime" for the deadly attack by Hamas. While the letter provoked widespread outrage, Harvard itself didn't address the issue directly until two days after the letter was published.
The donor retreat is so bad at UPenn that one former trustee, Vahan Gureghian, wants the school's president, Liz Magill, to step down, claiming she is "not really up to the job of being the president of one of the eight or so most elite universities in the world.
In response, UPenn referred CNN to a statement Magill issued Tuesday, saying the school has a "moral responsibility to combat antisemitism and to educate our community to recognize and reject hate in all its forms."
The chair of UPenn's board of trustees, Scott Bok, said Monday that the "unanimous" sense among current and former trustees was that Magill and the leadership team "are the right group to take the University forward."
Why it matters
The dust-ups at UPenn and Harvard underscore a dilemma college leaders around the country face as they play the role of administrators, educators and, crucially, fundraisers.
Campuses are, in the American ideal, meant to be settings for civil political discourse, and it's on school leaders to balance demands from students, professors, and deep-pocketed alumni — all of whom tend to pummel their chosen school with diametrically opposed demands on any given issue.
In the case of the Palestinian literary festival, it's worth noting that dozens of Jewish members of the UPenn community wrote to Magill to express their enthusiasm for the event days before it was scheduled last month. They even criticized her for making a pre-emptive condemnation of antisemitism. Three dozen members of the UPenn faculty also wrote a letter in student newspaper The Daily Pennsylvanian to support the festival.
RELATED
Comments
Post a Comment