While the United States earlier this month avoided breaching the debt ceiling, its close brush with potential economic and financial catastrophe — along with the possibility of a credit downgrade — has resurfaced a perennial question: Is there a viable alternative to the quintessential safe asset, US Treasuries?
The short answer, according to most investors, is no.
President Joe Biden on June 3 finally signed into law a bill suspending the United States' $31.4 trillion debt limit through January 1, 2025, putting to bed weeks of concerns that the nation could default on its debt.
But the United States could still suffer a downgrade to its credit rating, even though it avoided losing its ability to make payments on time. Fitch Ratings warned earlier this month that it is keeping the country on watch for a potential downgrade by the end of September.
It's unlikely, however, that the loss of the coveted AAA rating from Fitch would impact Treasuries' status as the safe asset's poster child. In fact, Treasuries are so irreplaceable as a haven that a credit downgrade could actually spark a rally, said Benjamin Jeffery, vice president of rates strategy at BMO Capital Markets.
While seemingly counterintuitive, that's what happened in 2011, when the United States nearly defaulted on its debt and Standard & Poor's downgraded America's credit rating.
That's because investors are conditioned to seek safety during times of market turbulence. Treasuries are perceived globally as one of the world's most risk-free, if not the most risk-free, assets — and the United States nearly defaulting on debt has done little to change that.
In other words, "any credit rating movement would be more of an embarrassment to the US than an impact to investors," said Patrick Klein, portfolio manager at Franklin Templeton Fixed Income.
Several reasons underscore Treasuries' pristine reputation, including that no other country has a currency market that is as liquid, large or highly rated as that of the United States.
"The US government issues something the rest of the world desperately wishes it had," Josh Lipsky, senior director of the Atlantic Council's GeoEconomics Center and former adviser at the International Monetary Fund, wrote in May.
The US government has roughly $31.9 trillion of total public debt outstanding, according to data as of June 8 from the Treasury Department.
While the US government has come close to defaulting on its debt before, it's never actually happened. Moreover, the government is seen as a far more stable entity than a corporation, for instance, since it can impose taxes and take other measures to ensure it doesn't run out of cash. That makes it an ideal issuer of debt.
Other safe assets exist but pale in comparison to Treasuries. Gold, for example, is a haven prized for its price stability even when the rest of the market experiences volatility.
But the precious metal's prices are beholden to factors that government debt is not, including a supply that is controlled by miners. That makes the market too risky to underpin a financial system in the same way as the US Treasury market, said Olivier d'Assier, head of APAC applied research at Qontigo.
Moreover, Treasuries are denominated by the US dollar, the world's leading reserve currency — a position unlikely to be supplanted by another form of exchange such as gold, despite the value that it holds.
"It's not like we all carry around a bunch of gold bars in our pockets to use at the grocery store," said George Mateyo, chief investment officer at Key Private Bank.
Comments
Post a Comment