It's honestly pretty rude of the Swiss to work all weekend and make news while some of us are trying to chill. But I guess the burgeoning financial crisis was "urgent" or whatever.
So here's where things stand after a turbulent couple of weeks in the banking world:
First, the Swiss situation:
- After years of mismanagement, scandal and bad bets, Credit Suisse finally caved. Swiss authorities arranged a shotgun wedding in which Credit Suisse got taken over by its larger rival, UBS.
- Hours later, a group of central banks from around the world, including the Fed, joined forces to ensure that US dollars keep pulsing through the global financial system. The last thing anyone needs right now is a credit crunch that would only deepen the turmoil weighing on banks.
So, that was Sunday. Fast forward to Monday morning in the US, where the big question of the week is: Who's next? And will they be saved or allowed to fail?
And just like last week, the bank with the big target on its back is... First Republic.
The profitability problem
- First Republic's stock hit a new low Monday, tumbling 47% in volatile trading as the bank struggled to persuade Wall Street that it could remain viable.
- Shares were halted several times, and they sank further after a report from the Wall Street Journal said rival banks led by JPMorgan are trying to work on yet another rescue plan for First Republic.
So, for those keeping track at home: Yes, First Republic secured a $30 billion lifeline last week, and that was on top of a $70 billion loan from JPMorgan a few days prior. But investors aren't satisfied.
Why is Wall Street still worried?
There could be any number of reasons, but one major question mark hanging over First Republic is about its levels of capital — those safety-cushion funds that banks use to absorb losses.
Thursday's government-arranged $30 billion deal is essentially a big cash deposit (read: not a capital injection) that's allowing First Republic to pay out customers who are pulling their funds.
That deposit probably helped calm some depositors, but it doesn't solve First Republic's bigger financial issues.
The latest publicly available information we have on First Republic's financials comes from December of last year. That was just three months ago, but boy has it been an interesting quarter. One expert I spoke to said that there is "every reason" to suspect the bank's capital has taken a hit from its heavy losses on its bond portfolio.
The Journal's reporting also suggested the banks trying to stabilize First Republic are worried about capital. The paper said that the latest talks are "fluid and fast-moving" but have "focused on how the industry could arrange for an investment that would boost the bank's capital, according to people familiar with the matter."
Just to pile on: Moody's downgraded First Republic's credit rating to junk status Friday night, citing a deterioration of the bank's financial profile. S&P followed suit Sunday.
Good news and bad...
- The good news: Banks are definitely strained — they borrowed a record $153 billion from the Fed's discount window last week, a last-resort option for quick cash. But analysts and regulators are screaming from any mountaintop and microphone they can find that the system is secure, my colleague David Goldman explains.
- The bad news: All that borrowing signals strain, and that means banks may be resistant to lend money, adding more scrutiny to the creditworthiness of borrowers. That means fewer mortgages and less money flowing to businesses, which could slow the global economy and potentially lead to a recession.
- That's why central banks stepped in on Sunday, in a coordinated action like we haven't seen since the European debt crisis a decade ago. They're acknowledging for the first time since Silicon Valley Bank failed earlier this month that the crisis could do real damage to the global economy.
Bottom line: First Republic — hot on the heels of Credit Suisse, Silicon Valley Bank and Signature — appears most likely to be the next wobbly domino to fall. But perhaps the more important question is, will it be the last?
RELATED COVERAGE
- CNN: In the latest banking crisis, it's one big problem down, too many others left to go
- Bloomberg: The 11 days of turmoil that brought down four banks and left a fifth teetering
- WSJ: JPMorgan CEO Jamie Dimon is leading efforts to craft a new First Republic Bank rescue plan
- FT: How the Swiss 'trinity' forced UBS to save Credit Suisse
- CNN: What are AT1 bonds, and why are Credit Suisse's now worthless?
Comments
Post a Comment